The READIN Family Album
Me and Gary, brooding (September 2004)


Jeremy's journal

I was born with a mind that suffers from the incurable disease of worrying precisely about what could or might have been.

Cipriano Algor

(This is a page from my archives)
Front page
More recent posts
Older posts
More posts about:
His Dark Materials
Children's Books

Archives index
Subscribe to RSS
Follow on Facebook
Follow video posts

This page renders best in Firefox (or Safari, or Chrome)


Chapter 4 of The Golden Compass: Sylvia and I are both, separately, trying to figure out why the Master sends Lyra off with Mrs. Coulter, who is obviously a Bad Guy. Sylvia laid out her hypothesis to me:

Sylvia: Dad? What is that thing the Master gave Lyra? What did he say it could do?

Me: The Alethiometer you mean? He said it was a machine that would tell her the truth.

Sylvia: ...I think it's going to tell her that she's a Gobbler. He knows it and he wants it to tell her.

Me: Hm, that sounds like it could be...
(A minute later) If he knows though, why doesn't he just tell her?

Sylvia: Because she would probably just refuse.

That's a good thought. I also am working on an idea where maybe Mrs. Coulter's kid-stealing activities are actually benign, or serving a greater good, and we've been misled by the children's talk of Gobblers. The distinction between Good Guys and Bad Guys is not as clear in this book as in most of the other stuff we've read before. But I think Sylvia's idea is probably closer to right.

posted evening of Thursday, October 30th, 2008
➳ More posts about His Dark Materials
➳ More posts about Children's Books
➳ More posts about Readings
➳ More posts about Sylvia


(will not be displayed)
Remember info

Drop me a line! or, sign my Guestbook.
Check out Ellen's writing at

What's of interest:

(Other links of interest at my Google+ page. It's recommended!)

Where to go from here...

South Orange
Friends and Family